What Weโve Learned About the Would-Be Kavanaugh Killer
8 Jun 2022
BUCK: An update here on the armed man who was arrested right outside Supreme Court Justice Kavanaughโs home in Maryland. He went up to police. First of all, the fact that there are still protests going on outside the justicesโ homes is wrong, but I guess weโre just supposed to accept that. Fortunately, thereโs a law enforcement presence at the homes, obviously, and there needs to be. But this individual, he has been identified as John Roske of California, Nicholas John Roske.
And he was carrying a gun, a knife and pepper spray, along with apparently zip ties, a crowbar, a screwdriver, and I may be missing one. He had all these implements, weapons on him. Clearly, this individual isโฆ In the NYPD, you would have called him an EDP, an emotionally disturbed person.
CLAY: Yes.
BUCK: That is a professional term used for someone who is crazy in a way that can be a danger or risk to himself or those around him. But it is also a reminder that when the political temperature rises so rapidly because from the very top โ whether itโs the White House spokesperson or top Democrat senators โ saying things about the revocation of fundamental rights and the destruction of womenโs freedom and the servitude of their wombs, et cetera, et cetera, people who are already susceptible to political violence and to motivations for political violence are more likely to act. And this is a highly sensitive moment for the country right now with these justices. Weโre still waiting to find out what the final decision is on Roe v. Wade.
CLAY: Which is why I said that I think they need to put out the opinion. I understand some people say you canโt change the process and the protocol. I disagree. I think you need to put out the opinion right now. And also that Chief Justice John Roberts needs to join the majority, make it 6-3, so weโre not talking about one Supreme Court justice being killed. Buck, I hate to even have to discuss this. But letโs be honest. This guy, by the way, Iโm reading directly from the affidavit, he โhad a Glock 17 pistol, two magazines, tactical chest rig and knife, a pistol light, pepper spray, zip ties and other tools to aid him and assist him in being able to break into Brett Kavanaughโs house.โ
Letโs pretend that heโs able to succeed and assassinates Supreme Court Justice Kavanaugh. Itโs an awful, awful thing, but he was trying to do this. And to your point, heโs probably got major mental issues. But heโs sane enough to have put together this plan to have found where Brett Kavanaugh lives, to have procured all of these attributes, all of these assets, in order to act on his plan. Letโs presume that he got it done, Buck. What happens? Think about how crazy this is.
Right now, thereโs a 5-4 majority to overturn Roe v. Wade. On the death of Kavanaugh it falls to 4-4. It doesnโt get overturned. And Joe Biden would have the ability to replace Brett Kavanaugh on the Supreme Court with a lifetime appointment because he has a Senate majority with the tie-breaking vote from Kamala Harris to be able to replace Brett Kavanaugh. Now, I donโt know how the American political establishment would react to effectively allowing a left-wing assassin to kill a Supreme Court justice and then allow a Democrat left-wing justice to replace him.
BUCK: By the way, I believe that is unprecedented. I donโt think has a federal judge of any kind ever been assassinated. I donโt know of any.
CLAY: There have been judges, but weโve never seen anything like this for a Supreme Court justice.
BUCK: Federal judges, yes, but Supreme Court justice, I donโt believe weโve ever had an assassination of a Supreme Court justice.
CLAY: To my knowledge, I donโt believe weโve ever had an assassination of a Supreme Court justice. And, by the way, hopefully we never do. People will say, why are you talking about it? Because this was this guyโs goal. He was trying to kill Kavanaugh so that Roe v. Wade doesnโt get overturned.
BUCK: And letโs remember, the person who works inside the Supreme Court, who leaked this opinion, did so with this intention, create pressure, create a political hurricane that would knock down the judges that were finally going to do what was constitutionally sound on Roe.
CLAY: Which is why I was so angry about the leak. Look, Bush v. Gore didnโt leak early, decisions on who was going to end up being the President of the United States. Itโs unprecedented to have a draft opinion leak like this. And what it did was put a target directly on the five justices in the majority because if this is going to be a 5-4 decisionโฆ
And again, I would continue to say John Roberts, whatever his trepidation may be, needs to join and make this a 6-3 decision because the Supreme Court justices are still going to have targets on them if itโs 5-4. And the idea is one of them is no longer a justice, gets assassinated like this guy was trying to do, Roe v. Wade gets overturned in the other direction. So it needs to be 6-3 at a minimum.
BUCK: Judges traditionally have been quite safe. I just did a quick search on this. You can, fortunately, thankfully, count on one hand the number of federal judges who have ever been assassinated in 200-plus years of our history.
CLAY: Yes. Having said all that, this guy was trying to assassinate Brett Kavanaugh, and this is why the addresses being distributed so widely by Democrat protesters are so dangerous. This is why the White Houseโs refusal to condemn protest is so dangerous. All of this. This guy way may well be mentally disturbed, but the intent of his action was not mentally insane.
He understood that if he assassinatedโฆ Think about this, Buck. What would happen? Are we going to even be able to have another Supreme Court justice put on the bench? Would even Democratsโฆ? Would Joe Manchin think it was appropriate for Joe Biden to replace an assassinated Republican justice with a left-wing justice? This is the kind of scary calculus that weโre in the middle of right now.
BUCK: The federal marshals are the ones who protect โ
CLAY: Thankfully.
BUCK: โ federal judges. But with this decision from the DOJ currently to allow these continued intimidation protests, which are still ongoingโฆ We asked our friend Karol Markowicz about this in the first hour; theyโre still happening. They should not be allowed to happen. But as that is going on, it just creates more chaos, more problems, more noise. It makes securing and protecting these justices a more difficult proposition for law enforcement. Letโs be honest about this.
CLAY: Yes.
BUCK: More resources, more noise, more personnel and more resources necessary. More people that are around and in the lives of these justices at their places of residence. So I think itโs exactly what we said in the beginning. It was enormously irresponsible, the Democrat reaction to this. There are people who said that the leak was a heroic act, which is disgusting.
CLAY: Yes.
BUCK: Those people are morons. Unfortunately, there are a lot of morons who get paid plenty of money to be lib anarchists on TV. But this is a situation now where we seeโฆ Itโs days โ hopefully days โ away from this decision, what do you think, Clay, the next two weeks weโll probably get it?
CLAY: I hope. It seems like the fever pitch had been dialed down a bit, and then we get this news that broke this morning right before weโre about to come on the air. And my advice โ and I said it on the show, Buck, when I came right back after the news had broken, I said โ is weโve got to get this opinion out as soon as you possibly can because of the target thatโs here. I would just reiterate again, Chief Justice John Roberts needs to be in the 6-3 majority. Needs to support the other five justices.
BUCK: Heโs not going to do it.
CLAY: Iโm calling him out.
BUCK: I know youโre calling him out, saying he should. Iโm saying 10-to-1 odds, heโs not doing it.
CLAY: I think if he truly cares about the health and safety of the justices on the court he will, because my concern is this Buck, if itโs a 5-4 decision, the same motivations that characterized this attempted murder of Kavanaugh will also exist for years into the future as long as Joe Biden is in office and Democrats have potentially a majority in the Senate. And even if they donโt, then youโre back to 4-4. Itโs scary.
BUCK: You are talking about crazy people, and anybody who would engage in violence against a judiciary is obviously evil and a lunatic at some level. I think, though, Clay, if the decision comes down, the, โOh, weโre just going to reverse it back in a year or two,โ that gets really big. I know they say they want a court packed. I know people talk about this. But itโs a very different thing to say, โRoe endured,โ versus, โOh, weโre just going to switch it back.โ At that point, everybody realizesโฆ Iโm not discounting what you say, but I do think thereโs a difference. The pressure before the decision is substantially more, though, there will be a tail, a kind of an aftermath of this as well.
CLAY: I think in 2024, Democrats are going to run on, โWe have to win the presidency and the Senate so that we can put justices back on the Supreme Court to overturn this.โ I donโt think itโs going to go away.
BUCK: I think Iโve also been surprised by how little this has resonated. When I say movement, obviously the Democrat base itโs hair on fire. They completely freak out about this. But we really see what we would expect, which is what do the people that Democrats needโฆ? What does that middle 10% or middle 5% of the country care about? They donโt care about Roe. They care about prices inflation, the border, crime.
CLAY: Yeah, safety.
BUCK: All the polls show that. So I think the Democrats are, once again, going to have a hard time.
Recent Stories

Auburn Basketball Coach Bruce Pearl on Reaching the Final Four and Advocating for Israel
In an exclusive interview with C&B, Bruce Pearl talks about the Final Four and his advocacy on behalf of Israel.

Sen. Tuberville Defends the Trump Tariffs and Slices Up Men Fencing Against Women
Alabama Senator Tommy Tuberville joines C&B to discuss Trump's economic reset and the battle to keep men out of women's sports.

It's the Newest C&B Podcast Network Host, David Rutherford!
He's a former NAVY Seal and motivational speaker, whose show will be a can't-miss download.

VIP Video: There's No Need to Panic Over the Market
Clay and Buck counsel everyone to calm down and let Trump's plans play out.