ร—
Clay and Buck

Clay and Buck

For a better experience,
download and use our app!

Why Make an Infrastructure Deal with Santa Claus?

Clay and Buck

28 Jul 2021

BUCK: Clay, I want you to tell me what this turns into for the GOP. The senatorsโ€ฆ This just broke in the last hour. โ€œKey senators,โ€ here according to CNBC, โ€œhave announced theyโ€™ve reached a bipartisan infrastructure deal. Itโ€™s unclear if the plan had enough votes to pass.โ€ Chuck Schumer says heโ€™s prepared to push it through the chamber. They would need the 60 to overcome what is still a filibuster that would exist if somebody is going to exercise that.

And itโ€™s looking like Republicans, Clay, are going to go along with this. The Democrats have wanted to, as they say, โ€œinvestโ€ $3.5 trillion in social programs, plus something like a trillion of this is going to be actual infrastructure, and the text isnโ€™t out yet. But it sounds like weโ€™re just going to spend ourselves into oblivion. Is that the plan?

Playing on
Loaded: 0%
0:00
Progress: 0%
0:00
Progress: 0%
Current Time 0:00
/
Duration Time 0:00
Remaining Time -0:00
 

CLAY: While inflation is skyrocketing. And hereโ€™s my big question. And you tell me where Iโ€™m missing something, Buck. Most of the time when you agree to a compromise in legislation, the way to compromises workโ€ฆ By the way, Iโ€™m married for 17 years, so I also understand that all compromises (laughing) are not actual compromises. Thereโ€™s a lot of married men out there.

They say, โ€œYeah. Iโ€™ve compromised a lot. She gets exactly what she wants. Thatโ€™s how I stay married.โ€ It feels like this is that kind of compromise for the Republican Party right now. Most political compromises, you give up something that you didnโ€™t want to give up and you get back something that the other side did not want to give up in exchange for your compromise.

No one has been able to walk me through what the Republicans are getting from this infrastructure agreement. Let me give you a couple of examples of things that could happen. If Joe Biden said, โ€œHey, you know, Iโ€™ve proposed 43.4% capital gains tax,โ€ right now, itโ€™s 20%. So weโ€™re talking about roughly a doubling of that capital gains tax.

โ€œIโ€™ll walk that back to 28% in my $3.5 trillion deal if youโ€™ll agree to support the infrastructure bill that I want.โ€ Okay. I could see that. If Joe Biden is walking back his corporate tax rate, if heโ€™s walking back the overall tax increase heโ€™s getting โ€” and Republicans, in exchange, are saying, โ€œOkay. Weโ€™ll support infrastructure,โ€ the Democrats are giving the Republicans are getting and vice-versa.

But, Buck, given the fact that they areโ€ฆ I know this is a little bit procedural, but the Democrats are basically letting it be known that theyโ€™re going to pass their budget โ€” this massive tax increase, the biggest tax increase thatโ€™s ever existed in the history of the country in the middle of inflation.

They are doing this with the budget reconciliation, where they get 50 votes plus Kamala Harris to break it. What are the Republicans actually getting? Have you seen something where you thought, โ€œOh, this is a good compromise?โ€

BUCK: So hereโ€™s where we are: Collins and Sinema. So the key moderate Democrat in Sinema โ€”

CLAY: Yeah.

BUCK: โ€” and the key moderate Republican in Collins are on board for this already. Iโ€™m hearingโ€ฆ I was just checking with the D.C. source. Iโ€™m hearing that itโ€™s going to be substantially less, because remember, the text isnโ€™t out.

CLAY: Yes, thatโ€™s right.

BUCK: This is all a horse trading behind closed doors. What theyโ€™re doing is coming out. You have a bunch of senators now high-fiving each other. โ€œYeeeeah, thatโ€™s right! We have a deal,โ€ and everyoneโ€™s supposed to say, โ€œOh, great! Our government at work. Look at the amazing things they do.โ€

But a deal โ€ฆ that does what? They talked about the broad outlines of this, but weโ€™re looking at federal legislation here from the Congress. Guess what? The devil is in the details. So we canโ€™t even know exactly how much is being spent or what itโ€™s being spent on, but as to the question about Republicans?

Clay and BuckLook, Republicans โ€” and some people are gonna get a little bit upset, a little bit upset with this. This is true. Republicans like to spend a lot of money too! Republican senators. Remember the Congress wants to bring back pork to their district. That hasnโ€™t changed, and thereโ€™s no serious movement, underway, Clay, right now, to rein in spending and the debt and the deficit. There is no Tea Party, and not even the beginnings of one, today.

CLAY: Modern Monetary Theory basically teaches that deficits donโ€™t matter, and thereโ€™s no consequences for them, and thatโ€™s the era of magical economic thinking, in which we are living right now. But have you heard though? Your point of, โ€œHey, there are lots of Republicans who want to be able to go back and bring the pork back to their community.โ€

They get a bridge, they get a new road, whatever it might be. Much of this โ€œinfrastructure,โ€ by the way, not actually infrastructure when you actually look into the details of the legislation. But I just donโ€™t see any horse trading, so to speak, where I feel like Republicans are getting anything out of this deal other than giving Joe Biden an opportunity in 2022, to say, โ€œSee! I told you I would bring back bipartisanship.

โ€œNow we just need more Republicans eliminated so we can have more people who want to work and understand that importance,โ€ and if they try to drag Joe Biden across the finished line again in 2024, I can already see what his television commercials are going to say, which is, โ€œI made Washington work again by passing the biggest infrastructure bill in generations!โ€

BUCK: Itโ€™s really hard to run against Santa Claus. Republicans have learned this. Talking about the budget, looking at the math, the long-term projections, the challenges of funding Medicare and Medicaid going forward โ€” all those things that, remember, the Republican Party of ten years ago, was very much fixated on, very much interested in.

Although we didnโ€™t really accomplish anything in terms ofโ€ฆ Look, weโ€™re going to be at $30 trillion. The numbers speak for themselves. At some point, the scoreboard matters here. Weโ€™re going to be $30 trillion in national debt very soon, and so Republicans have spent. Look, under the Trump administration, we were still spending, spending, spending.

This is where weโ€™re going now, because the free-stuff people โ€” which you brought up MMT, Modern Monetary Theory โ€” is the party in power or just the political party in general says, โ€œWeโ€™re going to give you stuff, and other people are going to pay for it.โ€ That keeps working until financial catastrophe happens โ€”

CLAY: Brilliant.

BUCK: โ€” until the bill comes due. So right now, itโ€™s like both parties are on this train, throwing coal into the furnace, saying, โ€œLetโ€™s see where this thing ends.โ€

CLAY: At least if we are going to be on that train, can we not increase taxes? If weโ€™re just going to buy into the idea that budgets donโ€™t matter โ€” if weโ€™re going to do that โ€” what is the benefit at all, of increasing taxes in the middle of a pandemic? And thatโ€™s my big thing from the get-go.

BUCK: Oh, itโ€™s the right thing to do. As Obama would say, โ€œItโ€™s the right thing to do.โ€ Remember that? It didnโ€™t matter even if it hurt the economy. Itโ€™s about sticking it to the rich people. But as you know, it doesnโ€™t really stick it to the rich people. For all the talk that Bernie Sanders has of (impression) โ€œthe millionaires and the billionaires and the oligarchs,โ€ they can afford your 3% marginal rate.

Clay and BuckThey can afford to get rid of the carried-interest loophole. They can afford this stuff. Itโ€™s the small business owner who gets 150K, 250K maybe combined household income who is finally hitting their peak-earning years. Theyโ€™re the ones where all of a sudden, the lack of the SALT deduction really hurts and changes their long-term outcome.

Theyโ€™re the ones for whom the corporate tax rate really matters. And itโ€™s all about the politics of envy, man. You have to tell people, โ€œYou would have more stuffโ€ฆโ€ This is what Democrats do. โ€œWere going to give you that stuff! Itโ€™s other peopleโ€™s fault you donโ€™t have it, and weโ€™re going to punish them for not giving it to you before.โ€ Thatโ€™s what taxes are all about.

CLAY: Sadly, thatโ€™s correct. My argument is just, โ€œIn the middle of a pandemic, how is nobody standing up and saying, โ€˜Increasing taxes is the wrong move at this point in timeโ€™?โ€ It seems like madness to me.

BREAK TRANSCRIPT

BIDEN: (slurring) You may have heard that in Washington now โ€” I was just on the phone looks โ€” it like they reached a bipartisan agreement on โ€œinfrastructure,โ€ a fancy word for bridges, roads โ€”

CROWD: (applause)

BIDEN: โ€” transit systems, high-speed internet, clean drinking water, cleaning up and caffingโ€ฆ capโ€ฆ capping the orphan wells โ€” over thousands of them abandoned โ€” and abandoned mines, and a modern, resilient electric grid to build. And guess what? A lot of those (sputters) abandoned wells are leaking methane! And guess what? The same union guys that dug those wells, they can make the same union wage capping those wells.

CROWD: (applause)

Clay and BuckBUCK: Welcome back to the Clay Travis and Buck Sexton Show. This is Buck and that was Biden. He is currently, as we are speak to you, in lower Macungie Township, Pennsylvania. Heโ€™s trying to sell people on his American rules as well. A few things here, Clay. One: See? How are the Democrats selling this? Itโ€™s roads and bridges.

Itโ€™s also a Green New Deal Corps, kind of like the AmeriCorps or something, for people to become little social justice activists about climate change. Thereโ€™s $10 billion at least in the budget for that, and I think itโ€™s also fascinating that Biden is pushing Buy America rules. I donโ€™t know.

I feel like there was a president before Biden who was really into putting American products first, you can say. Buying from American companies, supporting companies that are here in America, and not putting them second, but first. I think somebody else was doing this beforehand. But then it was nativism; it was bad.

CLAY: Yeah, and all of this is so cyclically โ€” and I hate to be a cynic about all of this. But this is the conversation we were having earlier about the infrastructure package. Now, Joe Biden is going to go run around and talk about all the success heโ€™s had bringing bipartisanship back to Washington.

By the way, by โ€œbipartisanship,โ€ he means just a filibuster-proof majority. Sixty. So ten, roughly, Republicans are going to join this idea. And then heโ€™s going to shove through the largest budget with the hugest tax increases weโ€™ve ever seen in the history of this country under budget reconciliation measures that allow Kamala Harris to break the tie. The combination of both of those bills is going to be well over $4 trillion. So the end result, is going to be, I think, weโ€™re just pouring jet fuel on to a fire of inflation that is already burning.

Clay and Buck
Clay and Buck

Recent Stories

Get Password Hint

Enter your email to receive your password hint.

Need help? Contact customer service.

Forgot password

Enter your e-mail to receive your account information via e-mail.

Need help? Contact customer service.